I last year travelled on the RCI S of the S and the windjammer was certainley not 24 hrs and there was only the one outdoor pool.Having said that it was a most enjoyable cruise

Having been on many cruises on many different cruise lines, I believe the Halls would be quite surprised at the even higher level of service and better food on other ships...specifically those of Cunard, Celebrity, and Princess, and P & O (all of whom are superior to RCI). We have done two transatlantic crossings this past year, one on Celebrity Galaxy and one on RCI Navigator of the Seas. The Galaxy had notably better food and bar service. The entertainent, however, was excellent on both ships. Princess' overall package of food, service, and entertainment at a reasonable price is one of the best bargains on the sea. I encourage the Halls to experiment a bit and try another cruise line...they might end up as devoted to cruising as my wife and I